About the Menu

Island Cafe offers a straightforward and inviting menu that captures the casual spirit of a classic diner and breakfast spot with a coastal twist. Whether you're stopping by for a morning meal or a relaxed lunch, the menu features familiar comfort foods alongside distinctive local flavors.

Typical choices include hearty breakfast plates like traditional eggs and French toast, along with creative options such as the breakfast burrito. For lunch or a light dinner, you’ll find unique regional specialties like fried gator nuggets, fish tacos, and gator burgers, all fitting seamlessly into the laid-back Everglades City atmosphere. There are also wraps, sandwiches, and seafood combos that match the relaxed yet lively setting.

To round out your meal, Island Cafe serves classic desserts like key lime pie and pecan pie, each offering a sweet finish to your dining experience. The drink selection is simple and refreshing, with coffee and iced tea perfect for any time of day.

This menu reflects the easygoing character of the cafe, inviting guests to enjoy familiar flavors and local favorites in a friendly, no-frills environment that welcomes both locals and visitors alike.

Business Menu

Appetizers
Chicken Wings
US$9.99
Cheese Sticks
US$7.99
Fried Calamari
US$8.99
Onion Rings
US$7.99
Fried Mushrooms
US$7.99
Fried Frog Legs
US$10.99
Gator Nuggets
US$11.99
Fried Oysters
US$11.99
Fried Pickle Chips
US$7.99
Hush Puppies (5)
US$7.99
Cheese Curds
US$7.99
Mac And Cheese Squares
US$7.99
Salads
Chef's Salad
US$11.99
Carolina Chicken Salad
US$11.99
Caesar Salad
US$8.99
House Salad
US$5.99
Soups
New England Clam Chowder
Chili
Our Soup Of The Day
Sandwiches
Fish
US$11.99
Shrimp Po'boy
US$13.99
Oyster Po’boy
US$14.99
Chicken Bacon Melt
US$9.99
Bbq Pork On Garlic Toast
US$9.99
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
US$9.99
Steak Sandwich
US$11.99
Hamburger
US$7.99
Cheeseburger
US$8.99
Pizza Burger
US$8.99
Buffalo Chicken Bacon Melt
US$10.99
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato
US$8.99
Soft Shell Blue Crab
US$13.99
Grilled Shrimp Burger
US$13.99
Tuna Salad
US$8.99
Tacos
Fish Tacos
US$11.99
Gator Tacos
US$14.99
Shrimp Tacos
US$13.99
Bbq Pork Tacos
US$11.99
Wraps
Fried Gator
US$14.99
Buffalo Shrimp
US$13.99
Shrimp
US$13.99
Chicken Caesar
US$9.99
Fish
US$10.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch
US$9.99
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
US$9.99
Seafood Combo
US$16.99
Baskets
Clam Strips
US$9.99
Fried Oysters
US$14.99
Crab Cakes
US$13.99
Gator
US$14.99
Seafood Combo
US$17.99
Vegetarian Corner
Veggi Burger
US$7.99
Veggi Wrap
US$7.99
Cafe Specials
Hot Brown
US$13.99
Gator Burger
US$14.99
Cheddar Chili Dogs
US$10.99
Fish Reuben
US$12.99
Crab Cake Reuben
US$13.99
Quesadilla
Desserts
Key Lime Pie
US$4.99
Fried Key Lime Pie
US$5.99
Pecan Pie
US$4.99
Fried Twinkie
US$5.99
Peanut Butter Pie
US$5.99
Beverages
Coffee
US$2.50
Iced Tea
US$3.00
Lemonade
US$3.00
Soda
US$3.00
Bottled Water
US$2.50
Others
Pizza
Full Liquor Bar, Beer And Wine
Ice Cream Shop
You Hook'em We Cook'em